I finally got the new retweet feature turned on on my Twitter account today, and unlike Twitter lists, I find this to be a horribly designed addition. For example, take a look at this:
[image missing: original was no longer available in the Internet Archive]
How does this help me? Why is there no information telling me which one of the people I follow retweeted this guythe information about who retweeted it so small and easy to miss? [See UPDATE section below] If this were a tweet that I found valuable, I could count that value towards that person I follow for having the insight to retweet it. If this tweet were a tweet that I found useless, vulgar, offensive, or horrible, I could also count that against the person I follow who retweeted it, and possibly unfollow someone I really shouldn’t be following. Also, there’s no commentary from my friend telling me why he/she thought the tweet was worth retweeting.
As is, all the social goodness of the community-created retweet has been stripped bare from this item thanks to Twitter’s horrible attempt at institutionalizing it. I have no idea who shared it with me. I’m just left seeing someone who I don’t know in my timeline, which increases the chances that I’ll totally skim over it and not pay it the attention that I might have paid it had it been the avatar of a friend with a note and a RT.
If Twitter thinks this is the makings of a good social network, Twitter is doomed to be replaced in the longrun.
Stop dictating why retweet works the way it does[archived] and try building something useful for your userbase that enhances what they were already doing with a simple two characters.
UPDATE: As soon as I posted this, I saw this other retweet and noticed that Twitter’s “helpful” pop up telling me what a retweet was actually blocked the actual info about who retweeted it (which is there; it’s just very small and hidden). Here it is:
[image missing: original was no longer available in the Internet Archive]
So now at least I know that I should unfollow CtrlFollow for retweeting Paris Hilton, so that’s something, but everything else I noted above holds true. Even by design, that little note about who retweeted it is so small that if you’re quickly skimming through your tweets, you’ll still miss it / you might brush past a good share by a trusted source.




Leave a Reply